Industry News

Editorials > FW FEATURE: Movies that peaked in the first ten minutes

Call it premature cinematic ejaculation. Those films that, for one reason or another, have their best scenes far too soon and thus make the film slightly underwhelming on a first viewing (as we assume the rest of the film will be as incredible) and impossible to finish on a second.

The first rule of storytelling, chronologically speaking, is that your opening scene has to be incredibly interesting so as to draw your audience in. Unfortunately, these five films forgot the second rule: the rest of your film has to be just as good.

 

Desperado

The bar shootout in Desperado is not only the best action scene in the film, but also one of the best gunfights ever made. This is, to say the least, problematic. 

While the rest of the flick is decently interesting -- Salma Hayek's body double gets nekkid -- the film eventually collapses under the weight of its own action. At the film's climax, we aren't even shown the brutal gunfight between the Mariachi and Bucho's men: given how cool the very first gunfight is, the audience already understands that the Mariachi probably kills everyone and makes it out alive. It's a pretty unusual ending, but not a particularly satisfying one. Desperado opens with its greatest gunfight and continues on with action that gets progressively less and less intense.

You're probably better off just watching this gunfight, then popping in Once Upon a Time in Mexico.

 

Swordfish

Swordfish, unlike Desperado,  is not an otherwise enjoyable film which happens to be overshadowed by its great opening scene. Swordfish is a bad film (the kind that treats hacking like some sort of tech-driven form of sex), and its incredibly badass opening scene only exists to distract us from that fact.

Suspenseful, disturbing, and visually spectacular, the opening to Swordfish is everything the rest of the movie isn't. In a way, this makes the opening scene a relief; after watching the above video, one can live content that you really don't ever need to watch the rest of the movie.

 

Way of the Gun 

The last gunfight is admittedly pretty damned cool, but you just can't top a profanity-spewing Sarah Silverman getting her face punched in for sheer badassity. 

This opening, which has absolutely nothing to do with the film's plot other than showing Parker and Longbaugh to be total badasses, is one of the few outwardly hilarious moments in Christopher McQuarrie's otherwise straightfaced crime flick.

The rest of the film is good enough that it's still worth watching even after Sarah Silverman walks offscreen with blood streaming down her face ("You look beautiful! More beautiful than ever!"), but the movie never manages to truly outdo its totally pointless, totally kickass opening scene.

 

Hard Candy

Hard Candy's disturbing, unusual, provocative opening scenes serve two purposes, one intentional and the other not. Firstly, the viewer is meant to feel disturbed, concerned, and conflicted as the wide-eyed Ellen Page seduces and is seduced by Patrick Wilson; this confusion serves to make the film's big first-act twist (surprise -- it's a revenge flick!) even more shocking. The unintentional, but far more prescient side effect of this is that the rest of the film is never as confusing, disturbing, or downright unusual as it was during its first fifteen minutes.

A revenge film is pretty simple for an audience to digest, even if it comes equipped with some baggage about the nature of morality and character identification. Flirtation between a 15-year-old and a 30-year-old, however, is a hell of a lot harder for an audience to pin down or deal with. Thus making it infinitely more interesting to watch.

 

Saving Private Ryan

Spielberg's Saving Private Ryan can be accused of many things: sentimentality, hypocrisy, heavy-handedness. None of these complaints, however, can be accurately aimed at the film's horrifying Omaha Beach opening. 

Spielberg spends almost three hours convincing the audience that "War is Hell," but he really needn't have gone beyond this terrifying opening scene, which says all that really needs to be said. Without the hackneyed dialogue or overtly coincidental plotting, the massacre of hundreds of Allied soldiers without rhyme or reason really informs the audience as to what war is really like.

Ideally, one would watch the Omaha Beach scene, then leave before Tom Hanks can eventually be shot by the one Nazi he lets go free, or at least before the sappy "tell me I've lived a good life" epilogue.

 

Comments

DraytonSawyer on 06/13/2008 01:44am
I agree with all of this, except Desperado. While the film's best action does occur in that gunfight, the film's action is not so much what has made it a darling among some cinephiles and, especially, the latino community. Rather it's the "cool factor" that drips off the screen that has kept this film's cult following alive and well, as the characters behave in ways no reasonable human could, would or should...but goddamn if it doesn't look or sound cooler as it goes along. The fact that the Tarantino influence on Rodriguez's writing is overwhelming helps this along even more. And while definitely not on par with Tarantino's work, it's clear from the get-go that Rodriguez has taken that "vibe" and just jam-packed it into a blender of badassness and bravado directing. Its like something Frank Miller would write if he were in love with Mexican lore rather than bullets and broads.
Gilbert on 06/13/2008 10:35am
I completely agree , Desperado is one of the best pure action movies i ahve seen . It never aspires to be more than an entertaining experience at which exceeds .
jacktheweed on 06/13/2008 7:43pm
I might have to throw in War of the Worlds, Tom Cruise edition.
Great effects and tension created when the first ship came from below, then anti-climax
all the rest of the film.
DrZin on 06/13/2008 8:28pm
"In the Name of the Father"

Chase scene! With Jimi Hendrix! Wow! This is going to be greaaoooooooooozzzzzzzzzzzzzz . . .zzz
loganrapp on 06/13/2008 8:35pm
I have to disagree with the Way of the Gun assessment.

Yes - the opening scene, very pointless. But the film in its entirety is an excellent film-noir set in the southwest.

The film suffered from a poor marketing push trying to portray it as an action film, which it isn't, and the opening sequence certainly doesn't help with getting audiences expecting the same.

Not that I don't like to see Sarah Silverman, but I would've preferred that scene to be gone. I usually skip it on the DVD to get to the rest of the film, which is an excellent slow build where inference and silent acting is more important than the words actually said.
filmschoolstudent.com on 06/14/2008 00:33am
I totally agree with the comment regarding War of the Worlds, that movie was all down hill after the first 10 minutes or so, and the ending was a giant cop-out (even if it was written that way back in the day). As for Once Upon a Time in Mexico, that was just cool because of Johnny Depp, that guy is cool.
shanebroughton on 06/14/2008 00:49am
Captain Miller (Tom Hanks) was not killed by the Nazi soldier they let go. His group was attacked by an SS officer that does, admittedly, look similar.
david_morgan on 06/15/2008 02:41am
Shane, it's been a few years since I've seen the film, but I'm pretty sure it's the same German. That's why it's so significant and why Jeremy Davies' character decides to kill him after they've surrendered. He was the one who advocated letting the German live, only to have the same soldier kill Miller.

It's kind of a contrived idea, so I can't blame you for not believing it, but that is what happened. Not that it's the most reliable source, but Wikipedia says so too.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saving_private_ryan
fenrir on 06/16/2008 07:20am
Well i would argue that the highlight in "Swordfish" was Halle Berry topless, but other than that i can agree.
FatalError on 06/16/2008 1:34pm
David, Adam Goldberg's character was killed by the German that they let go. I've seen Saving Private Ryan about 4 times in its entirety and a half a dozen times in 1 hour increments on tv. This film does not suffer by having such an intense opening. In fact, it is the intensity of the opening that helps to maintain suspense throughout a good portion of the movie. After watching the Omaha Beach landing, the viewer is buzzing for a great deal of time. Any other great action scene in the first act or second act would just seem over the top. I loved everything about the film, from the characters, to the pacing, and feel that it does not deserve to be on this list.
david_morgan on 06/16/2008 9:42pm
FatalError,

Actually, I completely agree with you! I didn't write this article. Though he didn't sign it, if you go to the main page you can see that Anthony is responsible for this one. I think there are elements of SPR (for example, the aforementioned reappearance of "Steamboat Willie") that are ill-conceived but for the most part I think it's a great movie and one of Spielberg's best (which is intended as high praise, though I know and respect quite a few detractors who would say the opposite).

That said, you are incorrect about "Steamboat Willie" (the nickname of the German the unit let go, according to IMDb). Oddly enough, there is a Saving Private Ryan Online Encyclopedia. Check out these two articles:

http://www.sproe.com/s/steamboat-german.html
http://www.sproe.com/s/steamboat-comparison.html

I've made the same mistake myself. I think in the chaos of the final battle (a good sequence that I think could sum up the case alone as to why the Omaha beach landing isn't the only peak) it's an easy one to make.

Thanks for the feedback, anyway.
You must be logged in to post a comment. Click here to login or create a user account now